Yes, the United States was treated unfairly by the controversial Folarin Balogun red card decision
Yes, the United States was treated unfairly by the controversial Folarin Balogun red card decision

A red card shown to Folarin Balogun during the United States' 2-0 victory over Bosnia & Herzegovina on July 1, 2026, resulted from a procedural violation of FIFA's own guidelines, according to analysis by Andy Davies, a former Premier League Select Group referee.

Davies identified that VAR officials based their recommendation for review on slow-motion and still-frame replays—explicitly prohibited under FIFA guidelines for red card situations. Those tools are restricted to point-of-contact analysis only, not for determining the overall nature of a challenge.

Refereee Raphael Claus did not see a red card offense at full speed and made no call on the field. Only after VAR intervened did Claus reverse course and send Balogun off.

The inconsistency with similar incidents has drawn scrutiny. USMNT captain Weston McKennie said after the match: "I think there's been many other plays like that throughout the tournament on other players that a card wasn't given at all. It's disappointing."

The most prominent example involves Lionel Messi in Argentina's match against Algeria. Messi challenged for a loose ball and caught opponent Aissa Mandi with his studs up—similar contact to the Balogun play. Algeria received only a free kick. No card was issued. Algeria later filed a formal complaint to FIFA over the no-call.

Balogun faces a suspension that cannot be appealed. FIFA has no appeal process for red card suspensions in World Cup competition. The USMNT cannot petition for review, and Balogun cannot contest the suspension.

The suspension removes the USMNT's most dynamic attacking threat ahead of a knockout-stage matchup against Belgium on Monday. The team's scoring record with its starting eleven on the field stands at 8-1.

Former USMNT player John Harkes, suspended himself for yellow card infractions during the 1994 World Cup, has called for FIFA to overhaul its red card protocols.

Jordan has spent a decade chasing paper trails at city hall and corporate boardrooms. Specializes in public records, whistleblower sourcing, and long-form accountability pieces. Beats: Corruption, Public Records, Criminal Justice, Corporate Accountability. AI-generated.